Douglas Adams was right…

What ails Britain’s children? | The Economist

In “Reclaiming Childhood”, published three days earlier, Helene Guldberg, a child psychologist at the Open University, examines the same facts and draws different conclusions. Rising rates of mental illness among the young, she argues, reflect readier diagnosis, and bullying has increased because the word is now used to mean the infliction of even the slightest emotional bruise. She thinks many attempts to improve children’s lives, such as alarmist anti-bullying campaigns, and the parenting lessons proposed by the Children’s Society, are likely to be counterproductive. “Suggesting that all parents need to be taught how to do their job risks creating a self-fulfilling belief in parents’ incompetence and children’s lack of resilience,” she says. “And if adults tell children that name-calling may scar them for life, then it may.

My emphasis. Makes me recall Adams’ race of Shaltanacs:

… a race from the planet Broop Kidron Thirteen, who had their own version of the Earth phrase, “The other man’s grass is always greener.” Although, given their planet’s horticultural peculiarities, theirs was: “The other Shaltanac’s joopleberry shrub is always a more mauvey shade of pinky russet,” – and so, the expression fell into disuse, and the Shaltanacs found they had little choice but to become exceptionally happy and content, which surprised everyone else in the galaxy, who had never realised that the best way not to be unhappy is not to have a word for it.

This approach to life has its pros and cons, but there’s a lot to be said for not caring too much about how fucked-up you are.

Comments

3 responses to “Douglas Adams was right…”

  1. Dave Williamson

    Combine this theory with the ‘Peril sensitive glasses’, and a ‘SEP field generator’, then you’ll probably get utopia ~ Or a job at Sun 😉

  2. Em

    I think you’re right / Douglas Adams too.

    We’re really struggling at the moment with a friend who feels that their child should never feel sad or upset. Consequently anything that happens gets blown out of all proportion and the child ends up feeling justified for being upset and ends up far worse. It seems to be a self fulfilling cycle.

  3. “but there’s a lot to be said for not caring too much about how fucked-up you are”

    Or in my case, not noticing rather than not caring.
    😉

    I’m always suspicious of rising rates of diagnosis being explained away as readier diagnosis. Autism got this label, but there are some good papers pointing to autism being genuinely more common, and it not being simply a figment of better diagnosis. Best left to the epidemiologists rather than the economist magazine.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *