GEEK: How To (Kinda) Get An Edit Button For Twitter Tweets With One Weird Trick: #macroblogging

Historically, one of the greatest issues with Social Media has been one of sovereignty over one’s own content, or – put differently – the predilection for social networks, once they are past the initial growth spurt, to attempt to lock-down user-generated content (UGC) so that they don’t become essentially content-delivery networks (CDNs) for their competitors, and so that “promotion” of competitors is lessened in favour of indigenous functionality.

This has a grand anti-competitive history:

…and many others; a lot of this stuff dates back to 2010-2014 when the companies were indulging in daring, strategic, acquisitions rather than (of course) today when the selfsame activity is being castigated as “anti-competitive” and “monopolistic”.

One technique to get past this and to get control over your content and communications is “macroblogging” – which I wrote up extensively at the time [1][2][3] – and it turns out to have only gotten better and more effective over the past 8 years, as the platforms have converged upon the necessity of building good-quality “cards” and adequately rendering/importing content which is NOT hosted on their competitor platforms.

Macroblogging

Macroblogging exploits the big platforms’ hunger to import content from non-competitive small platforms, in order to turn them into precisely the kinds of CDN stovepipes that they fear becoming for each other. This is why a blogpost like this one will look perfectly adequate when rendered/shared on each of Facebook, Twitter and LinkedIn:

…even though it would look pretty terrible as a Tweet-Shared-on-LinkedIn or an Instagram-Shared-on-Twitter

Wasn’t Podcasting meant to achieve something like this?

If this sounds a lot like the utopia that podcasting was meant to create… yeah, you’re right. Podcasts are huge nowadays, but let’s be honest: Spotify, Audible-Amazon, Apple, Google and the others are attempting to become “Netflixen” of audio content, just as Facebook and LiveJournal and Blogger and the others essentially nuked independent blogging platforms.

Perhaps there’s a cycle of incarnation here – of centralisation for convenience and curation, and distribution for diversity, leading back to recentralisation for convenience again… but atop that observation it must be noted that the systematic murder of RSS-readers and decent feed-polling standalone podcast clients was a certainly contributing factor.

Web cards are a different deal to “Really Simple Syndication” or whatever; the big platform’s intent is to make your content look good enough for a click – so don’t skimp on adding a “featured image” or similar – but actual human beings will have a strong incentive to click through to your site, because any long-form content (and audio links, etc) will not have been captured by the platforms.

Plus: you will have an edit button, because it turns out that web cards are (to some extent) dynamically refreshed / can be updated to reflect modifications to the source material.

So, how do I do this?

In a sentence “Write Once, Share Everywhere”:

  1. Set up a WordPress Blog, ideally self-hosted; this avoid (e.g.) wordpress.com becoming specially-treated as a “competitor” to one or more platforms.
  2. Post everything, thoughtfully, to the Blog.
  3. Share your postings as URL-Only, or Mostly-URL-Only, on all the major networks; there are buttons / tools to help you with this.
  4. Explore and learn how to make the results look good.

The guidelines from the original blog post can actually be reduced to:

  • Macroblog blog post titles may be as long as you like
  • Macroblog blog post bodies may be as short as you like
  • Macroblog posts may contain what you like
  • Addendum: make regular backups for safety

That’s all. Give it a go, let me know what you think, in the comments below.

Comments

10 responses to “GEEK: How To (Kinda) Get An Edit Button For Twitter Tweets With One Weird Trick: #macroblogging”

  1. To find out what your post will look like:

    Twitter card validator: https://cards-dev.twitter.com/validator

    Facebook sharing debugger: https://developers.facebook.com/tools/debug/

    LinkedIn post inspector: https://www.linkedin.com/post-inspector/

  2. Tip: make sure to add a “Site Icon” (different from favicon.ico) by using the image-upload menu under:

    Appearance > Customize > Site Identity > Site Icon

    This image will appear on the left side of your Twitter cards, if there is no image associated with the posting. It’s a fallback.

  3. For Facebook shares which come up with ‘og:image’ as ‘blank.jpg’* you need the instructions on the following blogpost:

    https://jetpack.com/2013/07/12/add-a-default-image-open-graph-tag-on-home-page/

    …specifically the “function custom_jetpack_default_image()” stuff; and rather than edit files in your theme and lose the changes, you will need a “code snippets” plugin, like for instance:

    https://wordpress.org/plugins/code-snippets/

    • specifically: ‘https://s0.wp.com/i/blank.jpg’
  4. The major downside to this is that your blog then turns into something more akin to Twitter. More long-form writing like this, or like your good in-depth commentary on encryption and recent UK privacy laws, ends up getting mired in between posts with pictures of food, retweets of minor things, and posts where you LOL at Inspirobot. (To be fair, it is lol-worthy.)

    I added this blog to my RSS reader years ago (and then forgot about it as posts dried up) but have recently been torn between keeping it (for the aforementioned interesting long-form posts) or unsubscribing (because things like food pictures or cats in washing machines end up just being clutter).

    And yes, I realize this is also a problem with Twitter, which is part of why I mostly quit Twitter years ago.

    1. Hi Gabriel! That’s a fair and reasonable comment, and it’s been at the back of my mind for a while. Reviewing the logs shows a bunch of RSS readers and I no longer know how many real people are “behind” them, so to speak. I’ve assumed that the number is tending towards zero with the gradual death of RSS readers for most people, and I’ve been wondering about the disjoint between “an RSS feed for an unused blog” versus “a mixture of content reflecting all of my everything”.

      I don’t know how to fix it, but one possibility would be for me to start taking “tags” more seriously, and to show some discipline in this space, including feeds for the same. What do you reckon? I may actually post something regarding this.

  5. […] this comment from Gabriel, I have made a few changes to the feed structure and to use of tags, which I will try to stick to; […]

  6. Bill Sommerfeld

    I’m reading it via the newsblur RSS reader; according to newsblur, you have 16 subscribers on that reader.

    (And, wow, been a while since we last crossed paths…)

  7. David Edmondson

    I’m reading via RSS using rss2email.

    1. You are strange, Dave.

  8. Sheila

    I’m afraid I don’t have a subscription to your blog, I just click through from time to time from FB. I do however still stubbornly use RSS to subscribe to podcasts as I have a podcast player that allows me to build rule based dynamically populated playlists, similar to auto playlists in Windows Media Player, but better.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *