ibook fried

Well, friday evening just as i was wrapping up for work, after an interesting afternoon of meetings and internal blog-related discussion, i got back to my desk and opened up my iBook to be greeted by a zzzt! noise, and a pale glow emanating from a gap in the case, just visible in the rebate for the screen’s hinge.

That’s funny, thought I, whilst I wondered if this was normal and that I’d just missed seeing it before. That it was not normal was driven home to me when the case started to get rather warm there, and a thin stream of acrid yellow smoke befan to flow from the case.

Oops. That’s bad.

Kill power remove power lead remove battery shut down. MacOS was running just fine, but something associated with significant current and with driving the screen, had comprehensively died.

I phoned Applecare who gave me an immediate escalation to Level 2 support when I mentioned “smoke and fire”; they quizzed me – presumably to cover their arses:

  • was there damage to other equipment
  • was the fire department called
  • did smoke alarms go off
  • what was it plugged into
  • had i meddled with the hardware

…an extensive list of questions, which yielded exactly the same result as staying with layer-1 support, viz: they are going to mail a box to me to return it for service. The only difference I suppose is that in the extra couple of hours bureaucracy that they put themselves through, they missed the window to mail the box out on friday, so got back to me this morning with their decision.

Heigh ho. I am making-do with a colleague’s spare G4 Powerbook at the moment.

The iBook gets truly hammered – used 6 to 10 hours a day, 5 or 6 days a week, being opened, closed and ported around several times daily – so perhaps next time I should get a Powerbook.

Are they any more robust ?

Comments

7 responses to “ibook fried”

  1. Katz
    re: ibook fried

    Sounds like battery failure. There is a current recall for various Apple systems because of bad batteries, but my understanding is that it was for the G4-based powerbooks.

  2. alecm
    re: ibook fried

    ah, but this is a G3 iBook, and the battery is in the other corner.

    My theory is that a capacitor blew, somewhere between the point of entry of the power, and the circuitry that powers the backlight.

    that i managed to boot the machine with a dead backlight but functioning screen (shine a bright light on it to see what you are doing) and do a incremental backup to bring me up to date, all on battery power, may support this hypothesis.

  3. Ryan Matteson
    re: ibook fried

    The 12″ PB is supe rportable, and can stack up with the iBook. I have a 15″ PB, and it definitely a bit fragile.

    – Ryan

  4. Chris Morgan
    re: ibook fried

    > perhaps next time I should get a Powerbook. > Are they any more robust ?

    I use my 12″ 867Mhz Powerbook every day, sometimes intensively. It is ok so far, but I wouldn’t call it tough. The screen enclosure and the body have a bit too much flex for my taste. The rubber feet come off easily. I’ve burnt out one power adapter and the replacement has a flickery light. It gets excessively hot, and it also doesn’t like being connected to an external monitor whilst sleeping (this makes it crash, almost nothing else). There seems to be no reason to pay the premium for a Powerbook any more, unless you need line in or the fastest Apple CPU they sell in a laptop.

  5. alecm
    re: ibook fried

    …and dual-head; i am experimenting with that while i have the chance, to see whether it improves my life/work – that said, i gather some iBook video chipsets can be fooled into doing it, too…

  6. bartb
    dualhead

    I love the dualhead thing on the powerbook — with keynote it’s quite nice when doing preso (shows slide with notes on laptop-screen, shows slide on external output).

    I’m not convinced that the powerbooks do better lifetime-wise — they run very hot and the 15″ flexes a bit too much to be deemed sturdy.

  7. Stephen Usher
    re: ibook fried

    From your description it sounds like the plastic ribbon cable which connects the laptop to the display has come in contact somehow with the metal hinge assembly and has then shorted across it. This makes a lot of sense if you say that you’ve been using it a great deal and have been opening and closing the screen a lot as well.

    Of course, it doesn’t really matter what the cause is, it’s still broken.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *