post-ibook fritz confision

so, shortly before going on vacation my ibook video went on the fritz again – sporadic flashyness, shimmering-waves of grey and occasionally absolute deadness – so i phoned applecare for the second time in two weeks, fought my way through the inane frontline of call management people, and had a box delivered for service.

called monday, box arrived tuesday, serviced wednesday, box returned thursday; all jolly good stuff. as-per normal i thoroughly nuked my home directory contents before shipment, using the imac at home to fill-in functionality.

when i got it back the receipt said nothing more than:

full diagnostic and test
…which worried me somewhat.

last night – having returned from vacation – i booted the panther install cd with the intention of reinstalling the operating system, and was horrified to find the video image looking like this:

/users/alecm/albums/dropdata/di-img-2403.jpg /users/alecm/albums/dropdata/di-img-2404.jpg /users/alecm/albums/dropdata/di-img-2408.jpg

i immediately leapt to the conclusion that – as the chit had implied – some monkey had run diags on it and not found the (sporadic) problem that i experienced; this would be in spite of the lengthy explanation i’d given to the person on the phone.

however: being of a suspicious nature i fed some keywords into google and by great fortune stumbled across the following explanation [www.mymac.com] which fitted the circumstances perfectly.

this is – in fact – the only proof i have that my logic board was replaced by applecare, and i am glad that it was done, but it does mean that my panther bootdisks are if not useless then at least annoying to use.

having now experienced both the video problem [www.appleinsider.com] twice, and the power supply cable problem [www.macnn.com] once, i must admit to being really disappointed with apple hardware quality nowadays, as well as infuriated by what they’ve done to the applecare call centres – evidently there is an acoustic coupler in there somewhere, or perhaps a couple of soup cans and some wet string that provides the link to india such that you can barely hear the person on the other end of the line, for the crackling on the line.

i intend to raise the matter with apple, but i want to vent a bit first. hence this posting.

Comments

3 responses to “post-ibook fritz confision”

  1. mrod
    re: post-ibook fritz confision

    That’s a REALLY bad repair service. Not only is it not acceptable to send a system back with no documentation when they’ve installed hardware which is likely to cause problems for people when they have to re-install their system but actually building a system they know won’t work with the stock OS! It’s a recipe for generating problems for themselves as much as anything. It’s also very bad customer relations.

    As for the poor phone lines to their call centre, this will yet again cause their customers to start thinking of them as a tin-pot operation. It’s not going to help them break into the corporate world. Not when Dell give you 3 year worldwide on-site service for free when you buy their kit.

  2. bartb
    re: post-ibook fritz confision

    It took apple twenty days to send me a box (so I could send them my powerbook, which is suffering from stress problems in the screen…)– which they said they were going to do on the day I originally called them. So, now it’s going to be “approximately” ten days after I ship them the laptop before I get it back… which means I will not have had a proper functioning system for a month. Not impressed.

  3. yon
    re: post-ibook fritz confision

    <sigh> I had been thinking of investing in an ibook, both to have something more portable and because after my current laptop I no longer trust anything Dell-shaped further than I can throw it.

    I shall be watching with interest to see what Apple’s response is.

    yon (To be fair, it doesn’t yet sound quite as brain-dead as what Dell’s repair shop managed to do on behalf of the third-party vendors I bought the laptop from. I.e. replace the good screen I had with a faulty one, whilst totally failing to replace the dodgy video card that was actually causing the problems…. Still not exactly encouraging though.)

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *