Male circumcision is a weapon in the sperm wars

I’ve always considered circumcision to be an abomination – male, or most especially so-called female circumcision[1] – since it’s a non-elective procedure to no beneficial end, or at least no end that I would accept from the rationalisations given me, viz: “God told us to do it“.

Someone at last has taken a Freakonomics/evolutionary approach to considering male circumcision and come up with a reason that is plausible, if still no less an abomination…

Male circumcision is a weapon in the sperm wars – sex – 05 June 2008 – New Scientist

Circumcision and other forms of male genital mutilation have always been a puzzle. The ritual mutilations can leave the man vulnerable to infection and even death. So why do some societies insist on such a risky ritual for their men?

There may be an evolutionary explanation, according to Christopher Wilson, of Cornell University in New York, US. It could function to reduce a young man’s potential to father a child with an older man’s wife, he says.

Sperm competition theory predicts that males will evolve ways to ensure that their sperm, and not another male’s, fertilises a female’s eggs. Genital mutilation, in this view, is just another way to win the sperm war.

…article continues; it is both eye-opening and eye-watering.

At least it’s not quite as bad as Lions killing the cubs of other males…


[1] to truly comprehend the horror of the latter, read this book.

Comments

One response to “Male circumcision is a weapon in the sperm wars”

  1. Christopher Wilson’s database seems to come from the school of anthropology that ignores anyone who doesn’t wear a grass skirt. Male Genital Cutting is widely practised in the US, Israel, the Philippines, South Korea and used to be prevalent throughout the English-speaking world, none of them societies noted for polygyny.

    He deals only with the adolescent rite. Many societies shifted it to early babyhood, for the obvious reason that babies can’t resist.

    Wilson’s theories might help explain why the custom was instituted, millennia ago in Africa, Polynesiaa and Australia, but this discussion of circumcision as a memeplex (cluster of memes, units of culture, tranmitted by imitation) explains why it continues: http://www.circumstitions.com/meme.html

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *