Will Satire Change Anything? Will Blogging?

With so much that I have read in the press and media about how the likes of Jon Stewart are changing the face of US politics, and how the sea-change of brought about by blogging has permanently changed voter communication, this quote from Lehrer citing Cook brought me up short:

Tom Lehrer

When asked about his reasons for abandoning his musical career, he cited a simple lack of interest, a distaste for touring, and boredom with performing the same songs repeatedly. He has observed that when he was moved to write and perform songs, he did; when he wasn’t, he didn’t, and after a while the latter situation prevailed. It has been frequently observed that, though many of Lehrer’s songs satirized the Cold War political establishment of the day, that he stopped writing and performing just as the 1960s counterculture movement gained momentum. Lehrer has stated that he doubts his songs had an impact on those not already critical of the establishment: “I don’t think this kind of thing has an impact on the unconverted, frankly. It’s not even preaching to the converted; it’s titillating the converted… I’m fond of quoting Peter Cook, who talked about the satirical Berlin cabarets of the ’30s, which did so much to stop the rise of Hitler and prevent the Second World War.”

(my italics)

Comments

3 responses to “Will Satire Change Anything? Will Blogging?”

  1. Dave Walker
    re: Will Satire Change Anything? Will Blogging?

    Blogging may not be <i>changing</i> things as such, yet – however it does have The Powers That Be rattled (see eg news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/uk_politics/6191988.stm ).

    My own litmus-test for “when blogging changes politics” is when banners held aloft by marching protesters have blog URLs on them…

  2. Mark J Musante
    re: Will Satire Change Anything? Will Blogging?

    I like to think there are some benefits to “preaching to the converted”. There are those on the edge who just need a small push to convert, and there are those that are converted but lazy who just need a small push to become active. It sounds to me that Tom Lehrer just got bored and needed an excuse.

  3. David Sharpe
    re: Will Satire Change Anything? Will Blogging?

    a little off topic, as a Brit in the US and I would say one certainly converted (ie Liberal or in UK I would say middle of the road) I have observed that my OUTRAGE knob has been turned way down since the dems got congress and that the likes of Stephen Colbert got a bit less interesting. Though I still have to watch Jon Stewart and Bill Maher. Political satire in the US is in fact really tame compared to the UK anyhow

    This is probably because the removal of my civil rights at least appears to have slowed a bit, but then again, since we lost the right to the presumption of innocence I doubt the US will ever be the same again anyhow

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *