Interoperability as currently called-for …
- extends the social graph beyond individual platforms so that they crosslink with each other, leak disjoint identities, etc; see: XKeyScore
- sows confusion regarding any particular platform’s security (“…am I using E2E in this group chat, or not?”)
- any new, secure platform that gets big will be hobbled eventually, to the eventual benefit of state security and intelligence services
- provides natural opportunities for cleartext interception at “bridges”
- provides natural opportunities for downgrade attacks; e.g.: bridge Telegram users into iMessage chats, copies of everything end up going to Telegram
- provides natural opportunities for user error (“…oops, I sent that over SMS / Telegram Cleartext / …”)
- disrupts ongoing e2ee development (“…they can all switch to Matrix” / “…they can just implement MLS, which is still a draft standard…”)
Leave a Reply